Thursday, January 7. 2016Shay #5 from Brian Davies January 2016Shay update, January 2016: Happy New Year! My last report here regarding the Shay was back in September. I had fully intended to do a report following my three week trip up to IRM in October, but life has a way of intervening. It also doesn't help matters that I tend to like machining, painting, and mechanical work better than putting my thoughts on paper. But, here we go. As Nigel has been reporting, great progress has been made since my last report towards returning the Shay to service. I will try to put some names down here to thank and acknowledge those who have helped on the Shay for all of their hard work. I will undoubtedly miss names, and to those people, I can't thank you enough for all of your continued help on this project. When you great blog readers visit IRM, please remember that everything you see running and restored is thanks to the hard work of our volunteers and the generosity of our donors. Thank you all! On to the Shay. During my three week vacation work was progressing on the Shay on a daily basis. Many volunteers came in on weekdays when normally no one is in the shop, and this help really pushed our project forward. As Nigel has already given descriptions of much of what has been accomplished on the Shay during my three week "vacation" and leading up to today, I will attempt to add what I can to what he has already covered. As of now all of the work to properly seal and form the ends of every boiler tube is complete. At IRM, we use the time honored, traditional methods of installing boiler flues used almost universally in the steam era. I can go into this process in further detail in a future blog if people would like, but suffice it to say for now that the methods we use take a lot of time, but result in a tube job that should give us a very well-sealed boiler for all 15 years of service until the next federally mandated boiler inspection. One stay bolt was found to be broken the first time we filled the boiler with water, and a couple of days later it was replaced. Trevor, with help from Ben, has finished preparing the inside of the water tender for painting with a protective coating. In the upcoming weeks Cody will be leading the project of painting the inside of the tender tank. As Nigel has reported in previous shop reports, the boiler on the Shay has passed its federally mandated hydrostatic pressure test. This major milestone will now allow us to proceed with the jobs of adding parts back on the boiler. The boiler on steam locomotives gets an insulation material applied to it. This is called lagging. Surrounding the lagging is a sheet metal skin called the jacket. We use a type of block insulation that, while quite messy and itchy to apply, works quite well and can withstand the pressure of engine crews standing on the jacket repeatedly while doing maintenance on the locomotive. Jerry has started the process of securing wires circumferentially and evenly spaced along the boiler which will be used to secure the lagging to the boiler.
The process of applying the blocks of insulation will begin shortly. This job consists of wiring individual blocks of lagging onto the boiler, one at a time, securing them to the previously mentioned circumferential wires to hold them in place. Once the insulation is applied, the task of refitting the jacket can begin. To prepare for this, several volunteers, including Jane, Ben and others, have been working to remove old primer and rust from the back sides of every piece of jacketing, and then priming and painting the back side to help prevent rust and keep the jacket in good condition. We have thus far held off on doing any cleaning up of the outside surface of the jacket, other than removing old grease and oil, until we decide whether to paint the locomotive over this winter or not. Painting takes a good amount of volunteer time that may otherwise be needed for other mechanical projects to get the locomotive into operating condition. If the mechanical side of the project continues at a good pace, some paint work may start in the next few months. Once the lagging and jacketing is installed, work can then turn to reinstalling all of the piping necessary to make the locomotive operable. This includes water delivery pipes, steam pipes to the various appliances, and air piping for the bell, sanders, and brake system, as well as related brake control stands in the cab. During the Shay's whole operating life, from the time it was built to the time it was retired from regular service, it burned oil as its fuel source. When the Shay was converted to burn coal by the Chicago and North Western Railway in preparation for its arrival at IRM in the late 1960's, an industrial grate system was installed. These grates performed generally well over the years. However, as they were not designed for locomotive use, they were at times cantankerous and hard to rock in order to clean clinker and ashes from them each morning. Also eventually, due to age and use over time, the grates would warp or break, necessitating periodic replacement. Around the time the locomotive was removed from service at IRM the decision was made to make the proper grates for this locomotive. To this end, Steam Curator Tom Schneider, following original Lima Locomotive Works drawings, made new wood patterns to have all new, proper, grates and side bearers cast. Phil and I spent time in the Shay's firebox in October measuring and laying out where the new studs will be welded in the firebox to support the new grate system. In the next few weeks the hope is that our welder Dennis, aided by Phil, will weld in these studs. Once this is done installation of the grate system and its associated linkage can be carried out. Another large area of the locomotive, the smokebox, has seen a great amount of work done on it in the past couple of months. All of the holes needed to rivet on the new bottom portion of the smokebox have been drilled, and the bottom piece was bolted on, awaiting riveting and welding to the old portion. Several of the rivets that need to be installed are in an area inconveniently close to the frame of the locomotive. Because of these close confines, normal riveting practices are quite difficult. To make it possible to rivet in these areas, Tom and Dennis designed a special fixture that will allow us to use the frame of the locomotive to our advantage to aid us in driving the rivets!
Hopefully Nigel can describe this in better detail in a future blog update. Once the riveting is done, Dennis will weld the new bottom to the old part of the smokebox. Soon after this is done, installation of the superheater units and other front end pieces can begin. To prepare for this, our machinist, Eric, has been busy machining a few newly cast pieces that were made to replace old steam fittings for use in the smokebox that were very heavily deteriorated from years of corrosion and use. There are always many, many small projects among the larger ones involved with locomotive restoration. One of these currently is replacement of several wood brackets used to secure lubrication piping above the motor unit. Over the years these pieces have rotted out to the point where they do little to hold the lubrication piping in place.
Phil and John have been working on replicating these pieces, and they should be reinstalled in the next few weeks. Being away from the museum as much as I am can not only make it a challenge to manage a project in a way that moves a project along at a good pace and keeps everyone happy, but it is also frustrating when I wish I could physically do more to help while I am not there. Because of this I took on a project for the Shay that could be done from home. It was quite common for logging locomotives to have steam driven water pumps on them to use for firefighting for washing the locomotive, and I am sure for various other uses. Our Shay has had one of these duplex steam pumps on it most of its life. Unfortunately, when the locomotive was retired and before it came to IRM the pump appears to have been removed from the locomotive. In the early to mid 1970s, volunteers replaced it with a different pump. While not the same brand of pump the locomotive carried in service, the pump is an appropriate stand in. In fact, while doing research on this pump, I found that the pump is older than the locomotive! This pump has not been operable in the time I have been a volunteer at IRM (starting in 1995) and even Tom Schneider, who has been with IRM since the mid 1970s, doesn't remember the last time this pump was operable. For many years I have wanted to rebuild this pump and return it to operation. I started working on it in April of this year, and I am happy to report that its rebuild was completed on December 23rd; my Christmas present to IRM, the Shay, and the steam shop.
If there is interest I can write a blog about the restoration of this pump at a future time. But for now, I am excited that the pump is again operable, works well, and will be serviceable on the Shay hopefully for years to come. Overall, work on the Shay is moving along at a fine pace. Much has been accomplished since my last report in September, and the list of things to do is growing ever shorter. We are still working towards the goal of seeing the locomotive operate in 2016. As Nigel and I have both mentioned, we are actively seeking donations towards the rebuilding of the Shay. Nigel has informed me that since his last plea for funds several donations have come in for the Shay. THANK YOU!! We really, truly appreciate every donation we receive. I think perhaps us members don't always express well how much we really appreciate all of you who donate money to preserve and rebuild our equipment, but we couldn't do the work we do without your help. So again, thank you very, very much. I would also like to say a huge THANK YOU to every member of the Steam Department who has helped on the Shay's restoration to date. Each of you will be to thank for the locomotive's return to service. This said, we always welcome new volunteers. If any of you reading this have thought over time, "Someday I would really like to go out there and try volunteering in the Steam Shop," well, why wait? The work is dirty and results can happen slowly, but there is a lifetime of learning available to those who are interested, and generally a good amount of fun as well. You don't need to know a thing about steam locomotives, but just have a willingness to listen, learn, and work. Come out and talk to us in the shop. There is always someone there every Saturday. Whether you are a donor, a volunteer, or a visitor to IRM, thank you for your support, and here's hoping that 2016 sees us have two of our own steam locomotives in operation for the first time since 1999! Brian DaviesComments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
It is wonderful to read your detailed progress reports on the Shay and realize that I might finally be able to see it in operation when I visit the museum. Thanks to all that are working on this project as well as all those working on the other projects in the Steam Shop.
#1
Kirk Warner
on
2016-01-08 10:13
(Reply)
Out of curiosity, why was it decided to restore the shay to burn coal rather than oil if indeed it burned oil during most of its operating life? I presume it originally burned bunker C oil but could it have been modified to use lighter oil? (If the original oil burning hardware is gone and lost to the ages, this would be a moot issue :) )
#2
C Kronenwetter
on
2016-01-08 10:16
(Reply)
Hello again Brian and All... Very nice blog and always informative. I seem to recall the water pump, you just restored to operation, was used in 1990's to fight a rather large grass fire down at the east end. I don't remember all the specifics but it was a good grass fire. We even had to call the union fire dept to help us extinguish the "blaze" Yes, the old fun days..... Roger
#3
Roger Kramer
on
2016-01-08 17:22
(Reply)
with its current work rate, i just thought up a consist for members day 2016.
Shay 5
Water Tender
Dump Car 39
CNW wrecker 6363 w/flat
X-23 MOW boxcar
Belt Railway Caboose 223
#4
Raphael
on
2016-01-11 18:12
(Reply)
Hi All,
To answer a few questions here:
The decision to convert the shay to burn coal was made before the locomotive got to IRM. It was converted for IRM by the Chicago and North Western Railway. I do not have any first hand information as to why they decided to convert the locomotive. I suspect the decision was based on the knowledge base of the people who would be running the shay at that time and the logistics of storing oil on property back then. It could be converted back to oil if we wanted to. However, Steam Curator Tom Schneider decided long ago to keep the shay as a coal burner, and he went through the time and effort to make the patterns to have a proper Lima grate system cast for the locomotive. When converted earlier, an industrial grate system was installed. It worked fine for years, but we ran out of spare grates, and that grate system was flimsier than the proper system. I would like to see the shay burn oil, but I am also quite excited to five her again, this time with the right grates!
Roger, you may be right about the pump. I don't know. I do know that it will be usable again now! I look forward to using it to wash the locomotive on occasion.
Raphael, that sounds like a fun train to pull and a fun one to shoot pictures of. That being said, at present that consist is a way off from being able to happen. The 6363 currently needs some attention to at least one of its trucks before it gets used in an actual train again. However, I wouldn't mind seeing that consist behind the shay someday!
#4.1
Brian Davies
on
2016-02-06 20:04
(Reply)
Brian (and/or Nigel)
Didn't the Shay originally have a snow plow? If so what became of it? Does IRM still have it? The reasons I ask is: AKAIK no other Shay in the country, operational or display, has a snowplow, so it's very unusual in that regard. The second reason: since I build 7-1/2" gauge Live Steam locos, I'm interested in getting the dimensions and other details/particulars of the plow when I come to visit, if possible. Thanks.
#4.1.1
Cabbage Stack
on
2016-03-21 11:38
(Reply)
Yes. #5 does have a snow plow.
How to deal with this has been a subject of discussion. When she last ran, and for how long before I do not know, it was still mounted on the front truck but had pieces fitted to ensure it could not be operated.
With all the switches at IRM, accidental lowering could risk serious damage and the likelihood of needing to plough is minimal.
Nigel
#4.1.1.1
Nigel Bennett
on
2016-03-22 12:40
(Reply)
Hello,
To follow up on what Nigel stated, the flanger/plow on the shay is essentially complete. The air cylinders for raising and lowering the mechanism were tested during the truck's rebuild. In the past the valve to lift and to lower the blade has been wired shut so that it could not be accidentally moved. The blade is also chained up to prevent this from happening. Once the locomotive's operational restoration is complete the air lines will be reinstalled and the blade tested and tweaked as needed to make it operational, but other than testing it, it will remain wired out of service and chained up to prevent any accidental use. Just as how the duplex water pump was rebuilt even though it will see very little use, I feel it is important to restore and maintain all parts on the locomotive, whether or not they are normally used.
#4.1.1.1.1
Brian Davies
on
2016-03-22 19:21
(Reply)
>>>"I feel it is important to restore and maintain all parts on the locomotive, whether or not they are normally used."
Excellent Brian! Well said!! That is exactly the direction I would take if it were me. Completeness sake and historical accuracy are paramount!
I look forward to the Shay running hopefully this year! When Railroad Museum announces that she will run for the public I will immediately go there as soon as practical! In fact we are probably not going to visit the Hesston Shay at Hesston Steam Museum this year, solely so that we can devote our time to #5 Shay run (we live a fairly large distance away)
Yours In Steam
#4.1.1.1.1.1
Cabbage Stack
on
2016-06-19 18:27
(Reply)
Add Comment
|
Blog AdministrationCategory TreeCalendar
QuicksearchCommentsEthan Armitage about A brief history of 9976 Mon, 09-08-2025 08:22 Good job on the Burlington Nortern 9976. OK. Jamie Kolanowski about New Acquisation: What is CN 15444? Tue, 08-12-2025 12:56 No new news that I have heard of thus far. Jamie Kolanowski about Burlington Northern 9908 body work Tue, 08-12-2025 12:53 I'll also be doing another update on it soon. Keep en eye out for that. Jamie Kolanowski about Burlington Northern 9908 body work Tue, 08-12-2025 12:47 A little work was done to it for Diesel Days this year. You'll see photos floating around for the temporary short term job that was done to make it [...] Johncrpenter about New Acquisation: What is CN 15444? Wed, 08-06-2025 13:01 Is steam car CN 15444 going to be coming to museum several times it was to be moved to muesum Lincoln Strickland about New Acquisation: What is CN 15444? Sat, 07-19-2025 18:56 Yeah, sadly it's still there as of 7/19/2025 Nick about Burlington Northern 9908 body work Thu, 06-12-2025 19:14 Its been 14 years guys, where is the unit? Like really? Did you guys misplace it? Or are repairs taking that long? At this point be might we will have [...] Steve Smedley about Milwaukee Road 33C update 3/23/2020 Wed, 04-09-2025 17:40 Jamie Thanks for the update. She's gonna shine like every thing else you guys do! Smeds James Kolanowski about Diesel Shop update 3/5/2025 Thu, 03-06-2025 16:28 Yes, there is a wye. Those two have been MU'ed on diesel days a year or two ago. Joe S about Diesel Shop update 3/5/2025 Wed, 03-05-2025 14:04 7009 number boards look good. Is there a way to turn a locomotive around at IRM? In case you ever had a mind to connect 7009 and 6847? James Kolanowski about Milwaukee Road 33C update Fri, 03-29-2024 21:26 We're slackers and spend more time working on the equipment in the shop than keeping all you readers updated. We'll work on it, but I'm sure updates [...] AJ about Milwaukee Road 33C update Thu, 03-14-2024 08:02 What happened to the Department Blog? It's been over 2 years and I still regularly check for updates, but nothing comes... Syndicate This Blog |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Powered by s9y.